Button presses do nothing in HomeKit

[cmaddennj]

I had to reconnect the hub to my Wi-Fi because I had to unplug my router briefly. My button no longer worked. I ended up deleting and adding the button back. I chose the option to use the button with HomeKit, same as before. The button and hub show up in HomeKit just like before and I was able to add the same configuration to each button click via HomeKit. The problem is now the button does nothing. Everything shows up at HomeKit and it's configured correctly it just doesn't do anything.
Anyone have any suggestions?

[cmaddennj]

@Emil I don't see that. I can add what each click does in HomeKit but nothing happens.

[Emil]

@cmaddennj does the button "wobble" in the Home app when you physically press it?

[cmaddennj]

I just tried factory resetting the hub, adding the button and to HomeKit, and redoing the configuration for the button via HomeKit and still none of the button presses do anything. Hard to understand why when this was just working for months.